WelcomeUser Guide
ToSPrivacyCanary
DonateBugsLicense

©2025 Poal.co

(post is archived)

[–] 3 pts

Despite liking 1911s, I wouldnt recommend them for a CCW. Particularly for attractive females, who generally aren't the poster child for "meticulous firearm maintenance and training". For that demographic I'd recommend a striker fired pistol like a Glock because they're stupid proof. You pull the trigger and it goes bang, and if it doesnt you slap the mag and rack the slide. Less worrying about whether Blondie remember to cock it, or flicked the safety off, or dropped the darn thing and blew little Timmy's head off.

Not as pretty, but a concealed handgun is a tool not a fashion accessory.

[–] 1 pt

Yeah 1911 dope AF, just ridiculous as a ccw.

For that demographic I'd recommend a striker fired pistol like a Glock because they're stupid proof.

A double action, snub nose revolver loaded with wadcutters is even more stupid-proof.

[–] 0 pt

Definitely simple to use, but with no safety (heck, not even a trigger safety for snagging), it's wise to carry on an empty chamber. That's going to leave you what, ~4 rounds in a typical double action snub nosed revolver in a common cartridge like 9mm Luger?

I'm not super confident that's going to incapacitate an assailant fast enough at the range I'd want to use a snub-nosed anything at.

Put another way, you're spot on about it being a good weapon for the "tee hee what's a gun crowd" but it's a good way for Blondie to end up in the hospital because an assailant took four rounds of dubious accuracy, clobbered her, and then bled out.

[–] 0 pt

no safety

Your finger is the saftey.

Definitely simple to use, but with no safety (heck, not even a trigger safety for snagging), it's wise to carry on an empty chamber. That's going to leave you what, ~4 rounds in a typical double action snub nosed revolver in a common cartridge like 9mm Luger?

You don't really need a safety when you have a heavy trigger pull that is typical for double action revolvers. Any revolver made after the 1950s will have some kind of transfer bar so that the firing pin is not resting directly on the cartridge primer.

Revolvers chambered in rimless cartridges are rare since rims are required for the cartridge to sit properly in the cylinder bores.

I'm not super confident that's going to incapacitate an assailant fast enough at the range I'd want to use a snub-nosed anything at.

.38 special wadcutters are highly effective at lower velocities. They have excellent stopping power with minimal recoil. Jim Cirillo relied on these during his days with the NYPD stake out squad back in the 1980s.

Put another way, you're spot on about it being a good weapon for the "tee hee what's a gun crowd" but it's a good way for Blondie to end up in the hospital because an assailant took four rounds of dubious accuracy, clobbered her, and then bled out.

3-4 rounds of .38 special wadcutter will get the job done. Blondie needs to train properly, because you don't need that many rounds to stop a would-be assailant in typical self defense scenarios. >90% of CCW incidents are resolved in 3 shots or less as per FBI crime statistics.