Lets start off proper. I am not arguing for the blackening of TV.
I can agree on the Egwene and Nynaeve lines. But I nearly always picture the coplands and congars as the niggers in the village.
Frankly I am more upset with the choice for Perrin. Loial i couldn't care less if they stick in a nigger as long as it speaks well.
The thing about the "diverse" society of RJ's WoT, is that all the characters all act human to a degree, regardless of race. The Tairen's for instance, are clearly described as the darkest niggers, but they sure do act ok, and speak normally in the writings. Sure they play some underhanded games in the palace, but so do the clearly short white Cairhienin, and obviously asian Altarans
Coplands and Congars, sure. Although I always saw them as the low-IQ white trash in the village, if they made them niggers I wouldn't mind (although they haven't, they cast a stereotypical Karen for Daise).
Loial is probably going to be covered heavily in makeup, and you'd be hard-pressed to find a white guy with the right build and vocal chords to play him (and according to the WoT wiki, "Due to their size and inhuman facial features, the uneducated often mistake them for Trollocs" which is both hilarious and accurate).
And for different regions, it makes sense if they're described as non-white in the books. I'm all for authenticity and
But for the Two Rivers main cast, it's a travesty. I didn't even notice Perrin, but that's bullshit. And Egwene's father is a fucking abbo.
Some of the castings are spot on though. Cenn Buie is perfect, as is Tam. Liandrin looks like she behaves exactly the same as in the books. Lan, Thom and Moraine look good, but it depends on their makeup and how they play the roles. And Padan Fain could be amazing.
I might end up torrenting the first episode to see if it's worth watching, but I don't have high hopes.
(post is archived)