You are off-topic
Check this sub's sidebar.
Even though replying to a reply about being offtopic is offtopic, it's relevant as it's a nuanced rules question. How is replying to someone's post which is on-topic with a relevant reply considered as off-topic? For all you're trying to do to promote discussion... This seems to counter that.
Your reply had nothing to do with the topic.
And you are again off-topic.
(post is archived)