520

•

Instantly site-banned for criticizing subreddit moderator /u/ani625.

On October 5th 2019, my Reddit account was permanently site-banned.

Disclaimer: I don't hate the concept of Reddit, but they falsely banned my account and made it impossible for me to prove my innocence, which is imminent suppression.

I was an avid contributor of a subreddit and my posts were well-received by the respective community. In fact, the trending posts were full of my posts.

Ani625 deletes all of my posts.

On October 4th, I discovered that my posts were suddenly gone (only visible to myself). Every single one. And the most recent post was by a user called **, who happened to be one of the two moderators of that subreddit. The post contained the same link I posted 10 hours earlier, a video from Louis Rossman.

The only way this could have happened is that Ani625 has manually deleted all of my posts. Despite my posts obeyed all the rules and were well-received by their community during Ani625's absence.

Also, I have noticed that my new posts are only visible to myself. I was shadow-banned by Ani625.

I contacted Ani625, asking why he has deleted all of my posts. Unsurprisingly, no reply.

I looked at Ani625's profile, and saw that he has more than a whopping four million karma points. Apparently the most popular Indian Reddit user.

Later that day, because Ani625 has entirely neglected my inquiry, I filed , but still, no action was taken at all.

To raise more attention and call for potentially more help, I crossposted that complaint to and .

The suspension.

While I was writing a comment on an unrelated subreddit (I can't remember which exact one), I was kindly greeted with a red bar that appeared at the top of my screen, informing me that my account has been permanently suspended from the entirety of Reddit.

For what exactly was I site-banned? For the crosspost to /r/powerabuse . It was labelled harassment. likely has some lobbying power and legal immunity, similarly to

For this one post, I was permanently banned from entire Reddit. If it was an one-day ban, a warning, or maybe a one-week ban at worst, it would have been OK. But a permanent ban is horribly exaggerated.

Failed ban appeals.

I have filed ban appeals explaining this the administrators, but the only responses I got were automated responses from the “Anti-Evil-Operators” (or similar) informing me that my ban is not lifted after a review.

After I explicitly asked the administrators to respond manually and teach me what I can do to get unbanned, I still got the automated response, which means that Reddit apparently automatically generates that response that my ban has been allegedly reviewed while it actually hasn't.

I had hundreds of Karma points when I got banned on Reddit in October 2019. As a new user, one needs to fight through annoying low karma and low account age posting restrictions. An anti-spam measure under which legitimate users suffer. All my efforts to gain those karma points were put to waste.

Being innocently surpressed like this is obnoxious and feels betraying.

Here are some more similar cases:

https://old.reddit.com/r/help/comments/ae41qy/account_randomly_banned/
https://old.reddit.com/r/help/comments/9t7kpd/admins_your_account_suspension_and_password_reset/
https://old.reddit.com/r/help/comments/b33wn7/can_you_appeal_a_ban/
https://old.reddit.com/r/help/comments/b90p4k/suspension_appeals/
On Wikipedia:
- by user Aron Manning.
- … despite *“Administrators are accountable for their actions involving administrator tools, as unexplained administrator actions can demoralize other editors who lack such tools. Subject only to the bounds of civility, avoiding personal attacks, and reasonable good faith, editors are free to question or to criticize administrator actions.”*

On October 5th 2019, my Reddit account was **permanently site-banned.** Disclaimer: I don't hate the concept of Reddit, but they falsely banned my account and made it impossible for me to prove my innocence, which is **imminent suppression.** I was an avid contributor of a subreddit and my posts were well-received by the respective community. In fact, the trending posts were full of my posts. # Ani625 deletes all of my posts. On October 4th, I discovered that my posts were suddenly gone (only visible to myself). **Every single one.** And the most recent post was by a user called */u/ani625*, who happened to be one of the two moderators of that subreddit. The post contained the same link I posted 10 hours earlier, a video from Louis Rossman. The only way this could have happened is that Ani625 has manually deleted all of my posts. Despite my posts obeyed all the rules and were well-received by their community during Ani625's absence. Also, I have noticed that my new posts are only visible to myself. **I was shadow-banned by Ani625.** I contacted Ani625, asking why he has deleted all of my posts. Unsurprisingly, **no reply.** I looked at Ani625's profile, and saw that he has **more than a whopping four million karma points.** Apparently the most popular Indian Reddit user. Later that day, because Ani625 has entirely neglected my inquiry, I filed [this complaint on /r/ReportTheBadModerator](https://old.reddit.com/r/ReportTheBadModerator/comments/ddb1dq/uani625_of_rapplesucks_deletes_all_of_my/), but still, **no action was taken at all.** To raise more attention and call for potentially more help, I crossposted that complaint to [/r/SubredditDramaDrama](https://old.reddit.com/r/SubredditDramaDrama/comments/de1zcy/misbehaving_moderator_uani625_of_rapplesucks/) and [/r/PowerAbuse](https://old.reddit.com/r/PowerAbuse/duplicates/de22u8/uani625_of_rapplesucks_deletes_all_of_my/). # The suspension. While I was writing a comment on an unrelated subreddit (I can't remember which exact one), I was kindly greeted with a red bar that appeared at the top of my screen, informing me that my account has been permanently suspended from the entirety of Reddit. For what exactly was I site-banned? **For the crosspost to /r/powerabuse .** It was labelled *harassment*. /u/ani625 likely has some lobbying power and legal immunity, similarly to [unblockable administrator *Bbb23* on Wikipedia.](http://web.archive.org/web/20191026212845/https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Handroid7/Bbb23#content1) For this **one post**, I was **permanently** banned from **entire Reddit**. If it was an one-day ban, a warning, or maybe a one-week ban at worst, it would have been OK. But a permanent ban is horribly exaggerated. # Failed ban appeals. I have filed ban appeals explaining this the administrators, but the only responses I got were automated responses from the “Anti-Evil-Operators” (or similar) informing me that my ban is not lifted after a review. After I explicitly asked the administrators to respond manually and teach me what I can do to get unbanned, I still got the automated response, which means that Reddit apparently automatically generates that response that my ban has been allegedly reviewed while it actually hasn't. I had hundreds of Karma points when I got banned on Reddit in October 2019. As a new user, one needs to fight through annoying low karma and low account age posting restrictions. An anti-spam measure under which legitimate users suffer. **All my efforts to gain those karma points were put to waste.** Being innocently surpressed like this is obnoxious and feels betraying. Here are some more similar cases: * https://old.reddit.com/r/help/comments/ae41qy/account_randomly_banned/ * https://old.reddit.com/r/help/comments/9t7kpd/admins_your_account_suspension_and_password_reset/ * https://old.reddit.com/r/help/comments/b33wn7/can_you_appeal_a_ban/ * https://old.reddit.com/r/help/comments/b90p4k/suspension_appeals/ * On Wikipedia: [**Bbb23** – administrator misuses his position and vandalizes Wikipedia.](http://web.archive.org/web/20191026212845/https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Handroid7/Bbb23#content1) * [… and silences legitimate criticism](http://archive.is/ZivXq#57%) by user *Aron Manning.* * … despite [Wikipedia's policies state](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Administrators#Accountability) *“Administrators are accountable for their actions involving administrator tools, as unexplained administrator actions can demoralize other editors who lack such tools. Subject only to the bounds of civility, avoiding personal attacks, and reasonable good faith, **editors are free to question or to criticize administrator actions.**”*

[–] • 2 pts

Welcome to Poal! It's a shame you had to find us under these circumstances, hon.

link

[–] • 3 pts

Thank you for your warm welcome.

Reddit is much larger, obviously. But at least, Poal seems non-corrupt.

Whoever rejects constructive criticism harms themselves.

parent
link

[–] • 1 pt

We have active admins committed to freedom of speech. I've even had the opportunity to criticize and be thanked for the contribution. However, nothing beats .

parent
link

[–] • 1 pt

Thank you so much for your warm welcome.

I posted this over at Voat.co too, and there is a low-life called , who posted:

You're coming on to Voat to complain about Reddit? No one gives a shit, OP. Unless you created original content, in which case you can assert copyright, you are pissing in the wind. You didn't own the content and you don't own the platform. Crying about censorship and "karma" is pathetic. Take your drama back to reddit and cry over there. Literally no one here gives a fuck.

…to which my reply is (as soon as I can post there again):

^{Sorry for late reply, because “You have reached your daily comment quota. Your current quota is 1 comment(s} per 24 hours.”)

Thank you for your pointless trolling. Are you happy now?

Your lack of sincerety is downright ugly.

Apparently, you often come to the Internet just for the sake of harassing users, not actual constructive feedback.

In addition, your post is a violation of Rule #1 (be civil). You're lucky I didn't report you. I will, if you persist in harassing users.

Stop wasting your time, and please never procreate your genes of ignorance and harassment.

But I have some questions left:

How can one expose misbehaviour of someone and make people aware of it, without getting accused of “whining”?

How else do you suggest me to have phrased it?

Also, how/where else do you suggest me to expose the misbehaviour of someone?