In USA, the SCOTUS has ruled time and time again, what is and is not free speech, and SCOTUS has two critical rules for defining "Imminent Lawless Action" : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imminent_lawless_action https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandenburg_v._Ohio To type something in a public forum, or utter it aloud in public, to be a crime, to be a "Imminent Lawless Action" it MUST not be a list of all targets of a class : *"SHOVE ALL JEWS INTO OVENS*" ... ...is free speech in USA, and well supported by SCOTUS and case law Furthermore is not imminent, because SCOTUS , time and time again, defines imminent as *UNDER 365 days*.