I'm betting that big hole is from water standing on top, popping out a bit in the freeze and growing from there.
Quite possible. Dad was a clever soul but he may have left the tops flat not realizing long term implications. I've been scratching my head about why that hole opened up. All I could think of were some kids must have been pounding a rock on it or something. Your bet sounds more plausible.
Is there an easy way to verify the center is ~¼" higher? Poke a thin rigid wire into the uncured cement to check heights while trowelling?
Build your forms 3.5 inches tall. If you're using molding for detail set that at the 3" mark. If not just notch a half inch out of one end of a piece of 2x4. Fill with cement to the top of molding and vibrate. Add a couple shovels to the middle. Put one end of a piece of wood on the molding and the other end on top of the form. Screed. Repeat on each side several times, adding or removing cement as needed.
Maybe I'll post about this with pictures when I finally get around to it this spring/summer.
(post is archived)