Hmm... 'N', 'E' and 'T' are already included in the "gimme" starter letters for the final puzzle: RSTLNE And you said she already picked "I" so she couldn't pick a second vowel. She couldn't have chosen those letters as you say you saw her do. I question your honesty. Edit: Or do you mean those are the letters she was choosing on consecutive spins and not during the final puzzle? If so, then I no longer question your honesty as that is possible.