Because ruling is not law. And the ATF has no such constitutional authority; per the constitution only Congress can. Ignoring the fact that the laws are themselves unconstitutional. Additionally, the frts are continuing to run through the legal process whereby the ATF has previously officially declared them legal - twice. In rewriting.
Very different positions and situations.
My statements are very clear and correct. Constitutionally Congress has no authority to defer and this is crystal clear. Constitutionally the ATF has no authority on this. Your confusion stems from your belief we are a country of laws and they actually follow the law or constitution.
The rest is simply statements of fact. Courts will side with the manufacturers unless corrupt. Which may well be.
Regardless, the situations are very different.
(post is archived)