It is wrong to drink alcohol because it might interfere with our free will.
It is right to take money from a poor mourning mother, because she of course understands all the theological intricacies about purgatory and indulgences, and the Catholic Church can do no wrong.
I have never said the Church, as construed as its members or clergy, can do no wrong.
I claim the Church can teach no falsity in its infallible Magisterium.
What I defend is the doctrine of indulgences, because it is defensible. If you think this doctrine was abused, maybe you're right - but that would be a fault of the abusers, not the doctrine, which is true in its own right.
(post is archived)