False. Yes it's improbable to get the exact same shuffle, but it could happen being as a fresh pack of cards is always the same order. One shuffle would be significantly higher odds. 3 shuffles, a cut, and a shuffle... Well I'm no mathemagician.
Still, it would be a pretty good magic trick to go over the odds and shuffle two decks to the same order.
it could happen being as a fresh pack of cards is always the same order
Yes this is the common caveat. The logic assumes the deck has already been shuffled.