Something would wake up. It wouldn't be me though.
Consciousness is an event. A chain of reactions across billions of neurons. The reactions stop, I stop. Because that is what I actually am; the reactions, not the matter nor the energy. Those are only the substrate.
You could copy the map of my neurons and start a new event that acted an awful lot like me, but it would be separate event with a rather hard discontinuity.
An engineering professor named Bart Kosko recognized this a long time ago and his solution was to replace one neuron at a time. That way the event that is you never actually stops but immortality is achieved at the end of the metamorphosis to 100% cybernetic neurons.
I think his essay was called "chipping away at your brain".
Other people still reject this and say it's a cute way of ignoring a robot slowly killing you by eating your brain.
I'm undecided. I still don't understand the nature of subjective experience well enough to say.
I'm 100% confident that straight copy would not be me though.
Bart Kosko is wrong though, as your neurons and their interconnections are evolving and changing all the time. It would end up as a mess.
I'm 100% confident that straight copy would not be me though.
It wouldn't be you, but for that copy, it would feel exactly like it is you.
Bart Kosko is wrong though, as your neurons and their interconnections are evolving and changing all the time. It would end up as a mess
With any near term technology, yes probably.
It wouldn't be you, but for that copy, it would feel exactly like it is you
Yeah.
We're kind of assuming digital simulations do have a subjective experience and aren't just philosophical zombies (en.wikipedia.org).
But if it can feel, it would feel like me. I just don't have much interest in conjuring up an entity like that though. I admit to having great interest in my personal immortality though.
Do you want there to be a digital ghost of you to persist after the real you dies?
I guess there could be some reasons for it. Like if you're working on a project that takes thousands of years to complete like terraforming Mars or something. Or if you want a mechanical ghost to look after your great great grand children.
I want none of these. When I die I will either go to heaven or go back to the same state I was before I was conceived and born. I will only know for sure the day it happens.