My wife bought one of these for herself, and I really don't understand the appeal.
You can easily just get an emulator on your phone for casual games, and there are phone add-ons so you can have joysticks and buttons.
Even then, isn't the appeal of retro gaming tracking down and using the original hardware?
I just don't get it.
Indeed you can install and play those games on any given machine these days
Like, you can launch street fighter 2 on a pc with the default mame interface... And play it with the keyboard, you can do that
Now I don't do that because it's totally pointless; you can barely play like that, it's more for testing purpose than anything else
Indeed, hardware is important, in fact you have games that are bordering on totally pointless without the original hardware or at least a suited hardware, games such as duck hunt or marble madness for instance. Playing duck hunt without lightguns is just... What it is I guess
So yeah you can install and play those on a phone, with some shit like that https://pic8.co/sh/VfaGtO.jpg
And then the neogeo snk original hardware is this https://pic8.co/sh/sWTMBQ.jpeg
I'm not saying there's a total incompatibility... But the button layout and the hand position aren't the same, like not at all, many games will feel awkward, same deal with most arcade games such as mortal kombat or street fighter 2, sure you can play those with a snes button layout, but even back then it felt akward to have strong kicks and punches on shoulder buttons... And then somebody calls on your phone or android update while you play... Side effect of playing on a phone, on top of that adding or removing games on a phone is a pain in the ass because it's a phone, and phone batteries tend to last as long as snow in the sun on top of that
I'm not saying hardware is everything, but in many instances it's almost everything
A bad joystick is enough to ruin a game, if anything that's what I'm saying, comfort is a thing
That being said, most of those games are made to be played on 4:3 screen, not a 16:9, the stretch effect isn't that a big deal for some, and for others it's just plain wrong
Edit:
So far, from all the machines I've reviewed the GPI case is the better deal to me (mostly because it's raspi zero based therefore fully customizable, it's potentially a full blown computer, not just a toy)
https://pic8.co/sh/9aG1N9.jpeg < raspi zero in the cartridge slot
That being said... I prefer the "mini bar top" formula, for the overall casing and input interface https://pic8.co/sh/IVC50u.jpeg it's not like I'm going to carry around a gameboy in my pocket anyway, I can't stand the phone to begin with
That, is typically sitting next to the computer on the table, to play games but not only, playing multimedia files/movies eventually, doing torrent box, mostly "read only stuffs" so a keyboard for inputs isn't that necessary, a joystick with the right settings and right OS can do. And again not just a toy, there's a "real computer" inside and I have 100% control over it, I'm not a fan of the retropie interface I prefer my own stuff. In the end that's what it's all about tbh, building my own stuff
Ultimately this casing is a pretty good idea, conceptually speaking, regarding the overall size/ergonomy, it's smaller than the above, but not too small
https://pic8.co/sh/KNEyhR.jpeg
Problem is that buttons and joystick (and the overall shit) is too cheap, I don't like buttons that do "clack!" I like rubber silence... And I don't like loosy joysticks https://youtu.be/KRqfxshC_MI?t=228
...
It's a chinese knockoff of the starforce neo ultimately https://youtu.be/KWIQfs6IdbQ?t=128
I totally understand what you mean when it comes to arcade games especially. You just can't beat the old school SOLID arcade buttons, joysticks etc. My confusion is when it comes to "hand held" games.
I appreciate the effort you put into your post, but I can't actually view the links of video yet (shitty chinese internet and shitty VPN).
If you're building machines, I'll have to give it a watch. It's a lifelong dream of mine to have an arcade cabinet -- either original or DIY. It'll happen when space permits I guess.
Well I'm more into software making, as in I make actual games (yes I really do, at least I'm not infringing any law by shipping them on a machine if I ever do...) and the minimal OS to run them on a given machine too, I also made a front end / game launcher recently, for mame/mednafen/dosbox, so I have a unified interface for radically different game systems and more eventually, such as movies and anything that is read only, such as my own apps, I also recompiled dosbox for my needs, stuffs like that
And yeah the hardware, I've been pondering it a lot recently. And that's going to be raspi based I believe, because that's just enough and it's dead silent, and it's likely going to be what's called a "bar top"/"table top" arcade type of machine, not necessarily as big as this one though, but that's the idea https://pic8.co/sh/HoVb9U.jpg
It's probably going to be one player joystick interface, half the size of this one, or rather 1/3. Something cute, like that https://pic8.co/sh/rUt7XY.jpeg
Min bar top/table top, in a nutshell, because yeah, a full blown arcade cabinet takes a lot of place
Ultimately that's what I aim for, some sort of modern day version of the jukebox I guess
(post is archived)