Welcome • User Guide
ToS • Privacy • Canary
Donate • Bugs • License

©2025 Poal.co

732
• (edited )
Federating Poal/Throat?

I'm not sure if this has been asked before, but has anyone considered federating Poal/Throat? Once one of the Reddit alternatives federate, they will massively increase in popularity. Is it possible that Poal could federate in the future?

Edit:

By federate, I mean as in 'The Federation' https://the-federation.info/ - https://fediverse.party/, it's a group of open source social media platforms like Mastodon, Plemora, PeerTube, Frendica, Hubzilla etc. By federating these social media platforms share all their userbase and that makes it so anyone can host their own instance of whatever social media and connect to other instances. This is what Gab intends to do by changing their platform over to Mastodon, which will make them uncensorable on the app stores because anyone can connect to their instance through other federated apps.

This is opposite of centralization where one server controls the entire system like Voat or Twitter. I hope that clears it up.

I'm not sure if this has been asked before, but has anyone considered federating Poal/Throat? Once one of the Reddit alternatives federate, they will massively increase in popularity. Is it possible that Poal could federate in the future? **Edit**: By federate, I mean as in 'The Federation' https://the-federation.info/ - https://fediverse.party/, it's a group of open source social media platforms like Mastodon, Plemora, PeerTube, Frendica, Hubzilla etc. By federating these social media platforms share all their userbase and that makes it so anyone can host their own instance of whatever social media and connect to other instances. This is what Gab intends to do by changing their platform over to Mastodon, which will make them uncensorable on the app stores because anyone can connect to their instance through other federated apps. This is opposite of centralization where one server controls the entire system like Voat or Twitter. I hope that clears it up.

(post is archived)

You are currently inside a comment thread.
Click here to see all the comments (12).
[–] • 0 pt

He seems to think that if voat, poal, and phucks all get together to make a meta-site, it will be a mighty empire of dumbshits, and he will be an early member. Also this throat place he seems to be talking about. Then he will revel in his power and prestige, and others will post only at his leisure, and he will be completely in charge of all white supremacy and antisemitism. Not to mention criticism of established government.

Also, then every quip ever typed by anyone outside of reddit can be used in federal hate-speech litigation without the need to spend so much time researching identities. Oh, look! Federal, federation ... hm.

[–] [deleted] • 0 pt

Voat and Poal definitely won't be coming together anytime soon, Voat is centralized and has their own agenda to profit just like Reddit. The Poal devs have already made use of federated tech through PeerTube and possibly Mastodon in the future. Here's my explanation of what I meant by federated https://poal.co/s/Poaldev/63353/6652c3a4-a085-472a-9d9c-5989d7c65264

If the Poal wants to be a true platform for freedom of speech, decentralization seems like the best way forward. By federating, no one would have control over the content of the website, as anyone could selfhost their own instance and submit their content to Poal if that's what the devs wanted.

[–] • 0 pt

My issue with the decentralization thing(and I'm not against it) is that if no one has control over platform at all then no one can stop people from implementing censorship.

I helped someone setup a throat instance just a few days ago, anyone can setup one up. Poal.co isn't exactly throat anymore but its still based on it.

[–] [deleted] • 0 pt

Federating would be decentralizing by allowing other instances to post on your website and vice versa. The instance owner can do whatever they like to their platform, they could make their website independent from other instances or simply only let a select few to submit to your website. If one of the instances decide to censor their platform then the user can either change instances or even make their own with different rules. I'm not sure how you could censor all the instances, I don't think that would be possible unless you forced every instance to follow your own set of rules.