WelcomeUser Guide
ToSPrivacyCanary
DonateBugsLicense

©2025 Poal.co

1.2K

(post is archived)

[–] 10 pts

Just pick up a rock, knife attack over.

So that's why they keep a pile of rocks in the corner of each train car. I always wondered. Thanks.

[–] 1 pt

Good thing I brought my travel rock.

[–] 0 pt (edited )

I am a "bring a gun to a knife fight" kind of guy, but if I find myself unarmed facing a knife, I will run! Run as fast as I can, I might even sound like SpongeBob, screaming the whole way. But if I can't run, its rock time!!

[–] 0 pt

Rock vs. knife? Seriously? You'll probably be stabbed or cut a few times before you land a solid bash with the rock.

You have the "run away" part correct- if you're unarmed (or concealed carrying, holstered), do not engage. Get distance so you can draw your weapon or just run as fast as you can. All it takes is ONE STAB OR CUT to the right part of your body, and you're fucking dead a few minutes later.

In a scenario where you cannot flee, and are unarmed, you should try to grab something BIGGER THAN THE KNIFE. A pipe, a broom handle, anything that can potentially keep the fucker out of stabbing distance. Using a rock as a bludgeon means you must get within "stab in the guts" range. Also most disarming techniques you'll see in shit like Krav Maga do not work on real, determined attackers- they only work on a student who is participating in the demonstration.

Your best bet, unarmed and unable to flee or find a good improvised weapon, is to go "2 on 1"- both of your hands controlling the attacker's knife hand. The attacker (and you, probably) will have a sort of tunnel vision focus on the knife. So when a struggle begins over the knife, their focus will be entirely on retaining the knife- this is where headbutts and such come into play.

Do you have any articles or videos of a knife attack being stopped by a guy bashing him on the head with a rock? I'm sure it has happened, but my point is that this shouldn't be your immediate option (which should be running away or shooting the bastard).

[–] 0 pt

You make some good points, when I say “pick up a rock,” I mean pick it up and throw it, pick up another and repeat. An un-hurled rock is useless. Give it some inertia and it will work wonders.

[–] 0 pt

Krav Maga

why would you learn martial arts from a race of spineless, limpwristed jellyfish?