Welcome • User Guide
ToS • Privacy • Canary
Donate • Bugs • License

©2024 Poal.co

268

(The melody of the linked song is also mirrored. The original starts with an ascending line; the mirror descends by the same intervals.)

At first I was going to link this 18-minute discussion, but it's not exactly clear or all that helpful. Just a starting point. But I figured the song was a better choice.

Essentially you end up with major chords becoming minor, minor chords becoming major, and scale positions being offset so that X ==> 7 - X.

In other words, the normal diatonic chords built off a major scale: I
ii
iii
IV
V
vi
vii (dim)

becomes vi
V
IV
iii
ii
I
"vii (dim)" (it doesn't exactly stay the same, but I doubt if anyone here would know the difference)

(The melody of the linked song is also mirrored. The original starts with an ascending line; the mirror descends by the same intervals.) At first I was going to link this 18-minute discussion, but it's not exactly clear or all that helpful. Just a starting point. But I figured the song was a better choice. Essentially you end up with major chords becoming minor, minor chords becoming major, and scale positions being offset so that X ==> 7 - X. In other words, the normal diatonic chords built off a major scale: I ii iii IV V vi vii (dim) becomes vi V IV iii ii I "vii (dim)" (it doesn't exactly stay the same, but I doubt if anyone here would know the difference)

(post is archived)

You are currently inside a comment thread.
Click here to see all the comments (10).
[–] [deleted] • 0 pt

Not exactly... I'm still working this stuff out, but there are a couple different approaches.

My approach is just trying to figure out how to reharmonize songs. This "theory" (or theoretical approach) just provides a formula based on a "reflection across an [invisible] axis". So one the one hand, CEG (C major triad) becomes GEbC (high to low), which is CEbG (C minor triad, low to high). But the chord built off the next scale degree, i.e. D minor triad (DFA) becomes Bb D F (i.e. not a "D" chord)

When you reflect a major scale across the axis between the 1st and 5th scale degrees (in this case, between Eb and E), you move into the parallel minor scale (and it's related, relative major scale). In the case of C major, you go to C minor, i.e. Eb major.

Back to my approach. I take more of a functional harmonic approach to determining what chords to use in a song. So that's where I derived the substitutions above

[–] • 1 pt

So Dm/Bb?

[–] [deleted] • 0 pt

Could you rephrase that?

Looking back at what I wrote, the connection between Dm and Bb is that they are "negatives" (really, reflections might be a better term, unofficially) of each other WHEN RELFECTED ACROSS [the pitch between Eb and E].

Reflecting the triads built off C major (Cmaj, Dm, Em, Fmaj, Gmaj, Am, Bdim), across [that pitch] gives (Cm, Bbmaj, etc)

Not sure if that answers or helps!

[–] • 0 pt

It's a dm with Bb as the bass note