There is no such rule posted; you cannot pick a rule for use in a particular thread, relating to a specific post. Additionally, there is no "blah blah blah" listed anywhere that defines this as being "uncivil" or otherwise unlawful. You sure like ignoring people's rights. If you wish to curtail peoples' free speech, you are required to note that in your rules...which you do not. So, according to heracleides, or in line with his thinking...illegals can be treated in any manner by the gov't including: having cruel and unusual punishments - so we can gouge their eyes out, cut off their hands, cut off their feet, cut out their unborn children from wombs, etc. all without trial. Or perhaps I misunderstand. Can the OP list what rights illegals may and may not exercise and that the gov't can curtail....this would be interesting.