What scenario exactly are you applying "forgive thy enemy"? You realize what it is saying right? It is not saying "apply a conditionally merciful justice system that stops crime and rehabilitates criminals".
It is saying just to forgive any enemy you have as a blanket statement. So if someone physically attacks you, you should just forgive them for it. Then do nothing while they go attack your neighbor as well. You can forgive someone when they right their wrongs to you, however. This was not specified, again.
Have you forgiven Bill Gates? Did you forgive Joseph Stalin? You forgave the Rothschilds? You forgave the nation of Israel?
I will say that the Jewed modern bible has many contradictions, thematic, metaphorical, and literal. If you want examples of Jesus applying justice, you could find them.
“Greater love has no one than this, that he lay down his life for his friends” (John 15:14)
I'm no biblical scholar, so my answer to this isn't perfect. However, I don't agree with doing away with carte blanche forgiveness. Personal pacifism has its utility. Having hate in your heart is deadly. Eye for an eye isn't justice. However, one should always seek justice in the defense of others.
Have you forgiven Bill Gates?
No, I hate the fucker. And Stalin, and the Rothschilds, and Israel. Gates wants to block out the damn sun, fuck him.
But I do recognize that it would be good for me and my soul if I removed hatred for anybody and everybody, even the worst of humanity. Nominally, I should view the sins of Gates and the Jews, and the desolation of their souls, as great tragedies.
The problem with what it says in the Bible is that it is unconditional one way or the other. All love and no hate. However all of these things are conditional. Even in the case of hating someone: the emotion of hatred is natural and should be expressed so that justice is obtained. Subduing your attacker with physical force, but sparing his life so that he can learn from his mistakes is an example of this.
This same applies to Jews, where one first needs to hate them and cannot forgive them until they are subdued. If unconditional love was applied, the Gates would go unchecked, and so on.
The problem with Jews is that their souls are not similar to Gentiles. Jews are parasitic souls designed to look human to subvert the Gentiles. This was admitted by top Rabbis. See the web article and video below:
This is why Satan is opposed to them. It is because they are almost the opposite of Gentile souls and are our soul enemies. They are parasitic whereas we are self sufficient. They want to sacrifice animals and nature, whereas we hold animals sacred. They want communism and hive mind, whereas we want independence and liberty.
Also, what you mention about removing hatred for other Gentile souls: Through spiritual advancement, humans have the ability to fix their souls and trauma that occurred to them. Nobody is doomed to be criminal or stupid or whatever forever. In this manner, nobody has to be put to death if they are willing to meditate and fix their souls.
As a real example of this, you can see people in this thread working on freeing their soul from past issues:
In this manner, everyone is accepted because everyone can be fixed with enough time and energy.
(post is archived)