This is one of those subjects where people have strong opinions. I usually avoid those subjects.
I'm putting this one here.
I'd like to hope we're better than the folks who remained on Voat and can actually have a productive discussion instead of just railing about Jews.
In short, this is a problem with Wikipedia. Now, how do we fix it? How do we work with it, knowing full well that there are edit wars and manipulations going on?
In other words, we all know it's an issue. It'd be more interesting if we can find a way to still make use of the site and get benefit from the site. Or, we can just rant angrily and not actually learn anything.
Seems like public an open logs would solve the issue at least in part. Its a big issue and does need to be addressed. You are not telling me I have to start a wikipedia clone too are you? I'm only one man.
The logs are there - there's the edit history. You can see all changes (by default) unless the admin has specifically removed the edit history and I believe those leave a note saying the edit history was tampered with. (They do it to remove links to child porn and things like that.)
So, the logs are there - but nobody regularly checks them. I can't even remember the last time I checked an article's edit history unless I was prompted to do so by someone else.
The truth is that we shouldn't be citing Wikipedia in the first place. We should be examining the links at the bottom and actually citing the primary sources - but we have come to use it as a citation source.
In ye olden days, you didn't cite the physical copy of the encyclopedia. It's not an authoritative source. You cited the material that the encyclopedia lead you to - citing primary resources and research papers, data, etc...
Well I think thats a losing battle. The ease of access the internet has given us to information even if its wrong has lead to people taking the path of least resistance and people like you and my self who seek out the truth at any cost will always find it but the masses thats a tough nut to crack.
Count me in!
(post is archived)