WelcomeUser Guide
ToSPrivacyCanary
DonateBugsLicense

©2024 Poal.co

1.1K

(post is archived)

[–] 0 pt

Serious question for you guys who know now about Bitcoin. What exactly holds up the value? What happens when banks disappear as we go into CBDC's? It's my understanding now that certain banks act as a go between in order to turn it into various currencies.

[–] 1 pt

Bitcoin has a few central value propositions:

1) It meets the criteria for a currency. It's divisible, portable, and durable. You might point out "Why dont we Runescape gold or pictures of Nicholas Cage then?" See #2.

2) It's non-counterfeitable and non-inflationary. Tons of people can print Nicholas Cage photos or dupe Runescape gold, but they cant create more than 21 million bitcoins. Why not just use gold or silver coins then? See #3.

3) Precious metals are slow and difficult to transfer. If you want to send the equivalent of $10 million USD in silver coins to Uzbekistan to buy howitzers, at best you can air ship upwards of 26,000 pounds of silver. That's going to cost you tens of thousands of dollars if you can air ship it at all. And take a day or two. Otherwise it's ships or rail depending upon where you are. Up that to weeks or months. Bitcoin will cost you <$2 USD in satoshis to do that. Why not just use paper currency that's backed by precious metals in a vault then? You can easily send a $10MM silver certificate within 24 hours. See #4.

4) Metal-backed paper currency requires a trustworthy third party to store, secure, transport, and audit those precious metals. That's expensive to maintain and impossible to hide. It's highly vulnerable to coercion or thieves with tanks because Gringott's Gold Vault is pretty freaking obvious. You have to trust that not a single person in the vault company has been defeated by a $5 wrench attack, otherwise how do you know your Gringott's Bucks are actually backed by anything? Bitcoin is inherently zero-trust. If someone transfers 50 bitcoins to your wallet, anyone can validate that the transaction occured "for real" without trusting anyone. It costs you nothing to maintain a wallet, it's impossible to tell how many (if any) you have, and you need little more than not sharing your credentials to secure it.

[–] 0 pt

I get all those points. What if who you're attempting to do business with doesn't have the ability or desire to use it. How are you going to be able to turn it to another currency if banks no longer facilitate that? Basically Bitcoin becomes a sandbox that only those who had coins before banks disappeared will be able to play in. When everything becomes a cbdc and the central banks refuse to interact with Bitcoin then the ability to exchange becomes nil. What happens then? How would one buy in after that?

[–] 1 pt

What if who you're attempting to do business with doesn't have the ability or desire to use it

Then they can use their Zimbabwe dollars or whatnot until their fiat goes to zero.

How are you going to be able to turn it to another currency if banks no longer facilitate that

Remember that bitcoin had on and offramps long before any bank got involved.

When everything becomes a cbdc and the central banks refuse to interact with Bitcoin then the ability to exchange becomes nil.

At that point fiat's value will be effectively zero. They're welcome to see how much food their worthless fiat buys.

How would one buy in after that?

Create a wallet, offer to sell your buddy a crate of ammo for X sats, exchange sats for ammo.