WelcomeUser Guide
ToSPrivacyCanary
DonateBugsLicense

©2025 Poal.co

773

I was searching here to see what people think about the Oppenheimer movie and to learn more about who and what the movie is about. What I found were discussions about nuclear weapons like the atomic bomb being fake.

This is the first I’m hearing of this, and my interest is piqued. Can anyone recommend a good video/documentary discussing the topic? I’m ignorant about all of this, and I want to learn about it. Thanks!

I was searching here to see what people think about the Oppenheimer movie and to learn more about who and what the movie is about. What I found were discussions about nuclear weapons like the atomic bomb being fake. This is the first I’m hearing of this, and my interest is piqued. Can anyone recommend a good video/documentary discussing the topic? I’m ignorant about all of this, and I want to learn about it. Thanks!

(post is archived)

[–] 0 pt

You're misunderstanding the purpose of nuclear bombs, particularly against largely wooden cities such as Japan had at the time.

Large scale firebombing against targets with negligible AAA are more destructive than individual early nukes. However, that's not the point. Nuclear weapons are golden beebees. Targets with heavy AAA (like the Soviets, hint hint) can cause 50% attrition on bomber raids and reduce the damage by 50% or more. Likely more since AAA prevented precision bombing of the era. Against golden beebees, it doesn't matter if you shoot down 50% of the bombers if any single one can carry a nuke that mission kills your city. It's like preventing pregnancy. You either need to stop 100% of the sperm or you're going to lose.

The USA used nukes to accelerate the war with Japan, but primarily as a show of force against the USSR.