My theory is that in order to achieve parity with low IQ people, they made math too difficult for the high IQ students to understand. You can't raise low IQ people up, but you dumb high IQ people down.
For that style of teaching to be tolerable for students, they had to experience the teacher as a colleague rather than as an adversary or as someone concerned mainly with grading.
This was the purpose of the Frankfort School. Moving all authority figures out of their position as superiors and into the realm of colleagues.
Intuition has its place but students at that age should still have certain things memorized and be able to do raw calculations.
I learned a lot of those things as well as the traditional items without the teach being a "colleague". My wife is a tutor, but gets me to help when it comes to math. They are teaching a lot of things that are useless to the 99.99%. And not teaching stuff that is very useful.
This kind of teaching isn't possible when the teachers themselves don't understand what they're teaching.
I don't think the concept was bad, I just the the execution was awful because the teachers couldn't grasp the concepts.
Makes sense.
Not all the students would be equally capable either. So even if the class was set up and properly ran by the teacher you would wind up with some kids being the leaders while the majority would follow and a few would just not get it at all.
On purpose.
Glad I never had to go through that.
Did you know about "New Math"?
Yep. Learned it in NYC public schools in the 70s and 80s.
I experienced it personally, they imposed New Math in my district when I was in fifth grade. For about two years, it was all Subsets and Supersets and other shit that was irrelevant to Basic Math. Then I was in 7th grade, which is Middle School here, and suddenly we were back to actual Basic Math, plus a splash of Intro to Algebra. That was when I fell in love with Algebra.
Several mention the lack of understanding on the part of teachers. This goes beyond just "new math". Most elementary teachers understand basic arithmetic but don't understand and can't convey the underlying concepts that kids need in order to do more than basic calculations. Some people will never need more than the basics but we handicap our brighter kids by providing them with teachers who can't give them the foundation needed to understand the math they will need in their careers that are more demanding than elementary school teacher.
(post is archived)