WelcomeUser Guide
ToSPrivacyCanary
DonateBugsLicense

©2025 Poal.co

1.5K

Used to be I could get a three-pack and it would work really well, you'd get a good rise and good airy bread. Anymore, it seems like every pack I get is different. One will work fine, the next won't rise at all.

I have a loaf rising right now, and it's not even puffing up.

Used to be I could get a three-pack and it would work really well, you'd get a good rise and good airy bread. Anymore, it seems like every pack I get is different. One will work fine, the next won't rise at all. I have a loaf rising right now, and it's not even puffing up.

(post is archived)

[–] 2 pts

Yeah, that's SOP. Still doesn't work. The yeast seems to be working, I get a good pop out of it.

[–] 6 pts

Are you using tap water? Chlorine is known to kill yeast, the ammt of chlorine added to tap water varies with water quality.

[–] 5 pts

I'm going to try with distilled water next time, because I also been having problem with dough rise lately. Will leaving tap water in an open pot for some time enough to get rid of chlorin?

[–] 3 pts

They don't use chlorine anymore, now it's chloramine (chlorine and ammonia I think). It doesn't evaporate.

[–] 1 pt

The technique of leaving tap water out to get rid of chlorine doesn't work anymore. They use something called chloramines nowadays.

I bet distilled would work well.

[–] 2 pts

It's heavily filtered. Just the smell of chlorinated water makes me retch.

[–] 0 pt

Try distilled to wake up yeast.

[–] 5 pts

Might be the flour, water's PH, and/or the temperature of the room where you store the dough.

[–] 2 pts

King Arthur usually gives me good results. I have some War Eagle for the next batch, I'll see how that goes.

[–] 3 pts

My local store has some Bob's Red Mill (unbleached).

I get amazing results with it and my breads/cakes taste great with it.

[–] 2 pts (edited )

Without turning on the oven at all, place a kitchen towel on the bowl in which the dough sits, and place it in the oven (a warm place - assumes you have a 30-40 yr old gas pilot lit oven), alternatively, if you have an electric blanket make a nest for your bowl, put the blanket on the lowest setting, towel over the dough bowl and wait. Sometimes the dough looks dead from bad yeast, but given time and a warm spot will have a better chance to revive and rise but it may take a long time even in the warm spots (check in an hour).

[–] 1 pt

I usually put hand-knead in the furnace closet with the water heater. It's nice and warm.

[–] 2 pts (edited )

In that warm spot, I'd give up after 4 hours before pronouncing it deceased.

I dunno, last idea: make a dough 'mouth' put a little milk and sugar in the 'mouth', re-knead after feeding it.