The urge to recoil from your genuine and kind-hearted church is the result of psychological abuse you suffered at the hands of your sociopathic, narcissistic family. It's the same as a dog that's kicked every time its owner smiles will learn to recoil from smiles despite the fact that almost everyone else who smiles at a dog does so out of genuine affection and kindness. That deep-seated childhood trauma created the defense mechanism where you're suspicious of kindness because as a child the appearance of kindness was exclusively used to manipulate you, rather than being wholly genuine and good-hearted in the case of your church.
I strongly recommend continuing to attend your church and enmeshing yourself in that community. These sound like genuinely kind people, and the more you spend time with them and avoid your cancerous family the more you'll learn to adapt your emotions and behavior to living a happier and psychologically healthier life. Once you develop close friendships within that church community I would encourage you to speak about your childhood with those close friends. They're good people. Some of them will "get it" and be able to provide guidance and support on how to recover from being the victim of child abuse. Those who don't "get it" because they've been sheltered from this type of toxic behavior will still be able to provide kindness and a sanity check on what type of behavior is acceptable and what type needs to be dropkicked out of your life with extreme prejudice. You likely have a great deal of hesitation there because showing vulnerability was straight up dangerous as a child (speaking from experience here...), but a good church group is going to want to give you the biggest damn hug in the world and invite you over for xmas and Thanksgiving so you have good people to spend the holidays with.
Regarding the physical vs psychological abuse, being more upset by the psychological trauma is completely normal. I know I would have preferred more physical abuse and less psychological, because bruises are a heck of a lot harder to rationalize as "acceptable" and a whole lot easier to use as evidence to get abusive parents thrown in jail.
(post is archived)